Trademark Infringement

What Is Trademark Infringement?

Trademark infringement occurs when an individual or entity utilizes a trademark or a comparable mark without the consent of the rightful owner, leading to potential confusion among consumers regarding the source of goods or services and violating the owner’s exclusive rights to employ the mark in commerce.

Here are some key points to grasp:

  1. Unauthorized Use: This encompasses any utilization of the trademark without authorization, irrespective of whether it pertains to different products or services.

  2. Confusingly Similar: The infringing mark need not be identical to the original but should be sufficiently similar to cause confusion among consumers.

  3. Likelihood of Confusion: This serves as the pivotal criterion for determining infringement. Courts assess factors such as mark similarity, goods or services nature, and target audience to ascertain potential consumer deception.

  4. Consequences: Trademark infringement may result in legal repercussions, including:

    • Injunctions: Mandates to cease the use of the infringing mark.
    • Monetary Damages: Compensation for the trademark owner’s losses and the infringer’s gains.
    • Attorney’s Fees: Covering the legal expenses of the trademark owner.
    • Criminal Penalties: Particularly for deliberate counterfeiting instances.

  5. Importance of Registration: Although not obligatory for asserting infringement, registration bolsters the case and streamlines the enforcement of rights.

Types of Trademark Infringement

  1. Direct Infringement: Involves using an identical or closely similar mark on similar or identical goods or services.

    Example: A company marketing shoes under the ‘NIKE’ brand name without Nike Inc.’s authorization.

  2. Indirect Infringement: Entails contributing to or inducing infringement by others.

    Example: Operating a website that peddles counterfeit items featuring a trademark.

  3. Trademark Dilution: Entails diminishing the distinctiveness of a renowned mark, regardless of potential confusion.

    Example: Employing a famous brand name like ‘Coca-Cola’ to sell unrelated products, such as toilet paper.

Cases of Trademark Infringement

Trademark infringement cases in India demonstrate the country’s robust legal system for safeguarding trademarks and addressing infringement issues. Below are notable instances illustrating various facets of trademark infringement:

  1. Starbucks vs. Sardarbuksh:

    • Case: In 2015, the emergence of a Delhi-based coffee chain named ‘Sardarbuksh’ utilizing a logo and color scheme remarkably similar to Starbucks.
    • Decision: The Delhi High Court ruled in favor of Starbucks, citing potential consumer confusion. Sardarbuksh was instructed to alter its name and logo.

  2. Britannia Industries Ltd. vs. ITC Ltd. & Ors.:

    • Case: Britannia Industries, renowned for products like Good Day and Marie biscuits, sued ITC, alleging trademark infringement. ITC had introduced biscuits under the brand names ‘Good Life’ and ‘Sun Sip.’
    • Decision: The Delhi High Court determined that ITC’s marks were deceptively similar to Britannia’s and granted an injunction against their usage.

Penalties or Punishments for Trademark Infringement:

  • Injunction: A court order prohibiting the infringing party from utilizing the mark.
  • Monetary Damages: Compensation covering the trademark owner’s lost profits, damage to reputation, and litigation expenses.
  • Statutory Damages: Predetermined damages established by law, applicable in specific circumstances.
  • Attorney’s Fees: In certain instances, the infringing party may be directed to cover the trademark owner’s attorney’s fees.
  • Criminal Penalties: In cases of deliberate counterfeiting, criminal repercussions may also be imposed.

Documents Required for Filing Trademark Infringement Case

Documents Required for Initiating a Trademark Infringement Lawsuit

  • Trademark Registration Certificate: Demonstrating ownership of the trademark.
  • Evidence of Infringement: Including copies of infringing products or advertisements, witness testimony, and expert opinions.
  • Statement of Damages: An assessment of the financial losses incurred due to the infringement.
  • Power of Attorney: If legal representation by an attorney is involved.
  • Court Filing Fees: Necessary fees for commencing the legal action.

Procedure for Filing a Lawsuit for Trademark Infringement:

  1. Evidence Gathering: Compile relevant documentation, such as documents, photographs, or samples, to substantiate the infringement claim.

  2. Cease and Desist Letter: Dispatch a formal notice to the infringing party, urging them to cease using the trademark. This step may sometimes resolve the issue outside of court.

  3. Legal Consultation: Seek guidance from a proficient trademark attorney to assess the case’s strength and devise a legal strategy.

  4. Jurisdiction Selection: Determine the appropriate court for filing the lawsuit, typically based on where the infringement occurred or where the infringing party conducts business.

  5. Complaint Filing: Draft and submit a formal complaint detailing the infringement, specifying allegations, and requesting desired remedies.

  6. Service of Complaint: Officially serve the complaint to the infringing party, notifying them of the legal proceedings.

  7. Discovery Phase: Exchange evidence with the opposing party through the discovery process.

  8. Pre-Trial Motions: File motions such as dismissal or summary judgment to address preliminary matters.

  9. Trial: Present evidence and arguments before a judge or jury for adjudication.

  10. Judgment: The court issues a final decision, potentially awarding damages, injunctions, or other remedies as deemed appropriate.

Defenses Against Trademark Infringement

  1. Fair Use:

    • Descriptive Fair Use: Permissible use of a trademark to accurately describe a product or service without misleading consumers.
    • Nominative Fair Use: Use of a trademark to refer to the trademark owner’s goods or services fairly and without causing confusion.

  2. Prior Use: Defense available if a party used a trademark in a specific area before its registration by the trademark owner.

  3. Abandonment: If the trademark owner ceases using the mark for an extended period, it may be considered abandoned, permitting others to use it.

  4. Genericide: Loss of trademark protection if a mark becomes widely used to denote a product or service category rather than a specific brand.

  5. Non-Infringement: Arguing that the use of the mark does not cause confusion among consumers and thus does not constitute infringement.

  6. Invalidity: Challenging the validity of the trademark registration, potentially rendering it unenforceable.

Other Considerations:

  • Non-use of the Trademark by the Registered Proprietor: Failure to utilize the mark for an extended period can result in its cancellation due to non-use.
  • Delay and Acquiescence: Failure to take action against infringement may weaken the trademark owner’s ability to enforce the mark in the future.
 

How to Prevent Trademark Infringement

  1. Thorough Research: Before adopting a new trademark, conduct comprehensive searches to ensure it doesn’t conflict with existing registered marks.

  2. Trademark Registration: Official registration strengthens enforcement and protection against infringement.

  3. Active Monitoring: Regularly monitor the market for unauthorized use of your trademark and take swift action to address any infringements.

  4. Legal Consultation: Seek guidance from an experienced trademark attorney to safeguard your rights and adhere to trademark laws.

Filing a Trademark Infringement Case with Vakilsearch:

  1. Contact Vakilsearch: Initiate a consultation by reaching out to Vakilsearch via their website, email, or phone.

  2. Provide Information: Furnish details about your trademark, the alleged infringement, and any supporting evidence.

  3. Assessment and Strategy: Vakilsearch experts will evaluate your situation and devise a suitable plan of action.

  4. Documentation and Filing: Assistance will be provided in gathering necessary documents, and Vakilsearch will file the appropriate lawsuit in the relevant court.

  5. Legal Representation: Vakilsearch attorneys will guide you through the legal proceedings, engage with the opposing party, and advocate for your rights.

Why Trademarkwala?

Trademarkwala is a legal services platform that offers businesses and individuals a comprehensive array of legal solutions tailored to their needs.

There are several reasons why someone might opt for Trademarkwala for their legal requirements:

Experienced team: Trademarkwala boasts a team of seasoned lawyers specializing in various areas of law, ensuring clients receive expert guidance and representation for their legal concerns.

Convenience: Trademarkwala provides online legal services, enabling clients to access legal solutions conveniently from their homes or offices, thereby saving time and simplifying the legal process.

Affordability: Trademarkwala offers transparent and cost-effective pricing for its legal services, with clients having the flexibility to select from different packages and pay solely for the services they require.

Range of services: Trademarkwala offers an extensive range of legal services, spanning from trademark registration and company incorporation to drafting legal agreements and resolving disputes, thereby allowing clients to fulfill all their legal needs under one roof.

Technology-driven: Leveraging technology, Trademarkwala streamlines legal processes, enhancing efficiency and result

Book A Call
Book A Call